Homeopathy Explained – Gentle Healing or Reckless Fraud?

Share
HTML-code
  • Published: 22 February 2018
  • What are the principles behind Homeopathy and does it work?

    Kurzgesagt Newsletter: eepurl.com/cRUQxz

    Support us on Patreon so we can make more videos (and get cool stuff in return): patreon.com/Kurzgesagt?ty=h

    Kurzgesagt merch: bit.ly/1P1hQIH

    The MUSIC of the video:

    Soundcloud: bit.ly/2BI1Wb5
    Bandcamp: bit.ly/2sJaEmh
    Facebook: bit.ly/2qW6bY4

    We would like to thank Dr. Natalie Grams, Dr.-Ing. Norbert Aust and Udo Endruscheit as well as Dr. Robin Fears and Professor Paul Glasziou for supporting us with our research.

    natalie-grams.de
    netzwerk-homoeopathie.eu
    gwup.org

    Quellen:

    Main principles of homeopathy:

    bit.ly/2En7XsQ

    bit.ly/2nmH29j

    Information Network Homeopathy Germany:
    bit.ly/2DEbSDO

    Homeopedia – German Online Encyclopedia:
    bit.ly/2DBII87

    List of homeopathic remedies:
    bit.ly/2DPPBUw

    Information regarding different homeopathic potencies:

    bit.ly/2kf8xB5

    bit.ly/2nobVtY


    Physical examination of dilution

    bit.ly/2EpX5dY


    Hahnemanns explanation for the efficacy of homeopathy despite dilution:

    § 270 Sixth edition
    bit.ly/2EwxkZr

    18th century medicine

    bit.ly/29LJFuD
    bit.ly/1R8Pp0W
    en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doctrine\_of\_signatures

    Hahnemanns rules for taking homeopathic remedies, Organon of medicine §260 Sixth edition:

    bit.ly/2rxz9T4

    Studies about the lacking efficacy of homeopathic products:

    Statement of the European Academies Science Advisory Council September 2017:
    bit.ly/2w94FET

    Australian Study from the National and Medical Health Council, 2015:
    bit.ly/1BheAmR

    Systematic reviews from Mathie et al, employees of the Homeopathy Research Institutebit.ly/2GaWI7x

    Statement from the FDA demanding homeopathic companies must prove efficacy of their products:
    bit.ly/2f71t3j

    Statement from the FDA regarding their approach towards homeopathic remedies
    bit.ly/2BLq1tF
    Quote: There are no drug products labeled as homeopathic that are approved by FDA.

    Placeboeffect:

    The Placebo and Nocebo Phenomena: Their Clinical Management and Impact on Treatment Outcomes
    bit.ly/2BlOMg6

    Placebo interventions for all clinical conditions
    bit.ly/2n5bfZs

    Components of placebo effect: randomised controlled trial in patients with irritable bowel syndrome
    bit.ly/2DCd9Ms

    bit.ly/2n5yYcS

    Placeboeffect on children and animals

    Caregiver placebo effect in analgesic clinical trials for cats with naturally occurring degenerative joint disease-associated pain.

    bit.ly/2DCdQW4

    bit.ly/2Dxpph8

    bit.ly/1n71rX2
    Homeopathy is big pharma:

    bit.ly/2DQjQqd
    bit.ly/23Faftl

    bit.ly/2FBe5wW

    Homeopathic anamnesis/ initial interview:
    bit.ly/2Ew3apa

    Exemplary questionnaire for initial interview:
    bit.ly/2nsQpnV

    Marketshare and market development for homeopathy
    on.mktw.net/2DxS0Tp

    bit.ly/2n5wgnG

    Further reading:

    Blog beweisaufnahme-homoeopathie.de (German, some articles in English)
    bit.ly/2E0NKc3

    ORGANON OF MEDICINE by Hahnemann Samuel (Original text)
    bit.ly/2EwxkZr

    Free ebooks on „Materiae Medicae” (German and English)bit.ly/2DtjNQW

    Deutsches Informationsnetzwerk Homöopathie
    (Short english version)
    bit.ly/2E3gP6P

    US Department of Health: Information overview about homeopathy
    bit.ly/1Nf0Miq

    Homepathic Pharmacopoeia of the United States
    (Official Compendium of Homeopathic ingredients)
    bit.ly/2n5GnZX

    List of over 5000 homeopathic ingredients A-Z
    bit.ly/2E0RCKj

    FDA warns against the use of homeopathic teething tablets and gels
    bit.ly/2DVtfB6

    THANKS A LOT TO OUR LOVELY PATRONS FOR SUPPORTING US:

    Flavio Storino, Alice Balcon, Hari Krishnan, Warren Wiscombe, Sara Zeglin, Asiryan Alexander, maarten sprengers, William Northern, Kerem Mimaroglu, Yana Kultysheva, Josh, Keaton Anderson, Croconaw, Peter Steinberger, Jonathan Diamond, Troy McConaghy, Paddy, Darko Sperac, Peter Burkhalter, Chris Amaris, Tyler Lovell, John Ruble, Chase Henson, Arpita Singh, Edward C.P., Andreas Edlund, Ryan Bubinski, Paul Greyson, Jerry Ding, Austin Sundquist, Daniel Link, Tim Johnson, kayleigh dreste, Johan Sjöblom, Max Stuart, Mush Rain, Andor Baranyi, Eduardas Afanasjevas, Bill Clem, Jake Smith, Stephen Woerner, Jeff Sorensen, Christopher Damsgaard, Eduardo AV, Michael Gawenka, Florian Hoedt, Lucas Nyman, Nathanael Baker, Martin Wierzyk, Mauricio Streb, Karl, Rameet Chawla, Joachim Andersen, Avinash, Erik Golden, Glenn Stoltz, Elliott Nelson, Andrew Averett, Ben Wei

Comments • 15 437

  • Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell

    There's brand new stuff in the Kurzgesagt Merch Shop. Check it out here: shop.kurzgesagt.org

    • aaradhy sharma
      aaradhy sharma  1 weeks back

      @ElPayasoMalo r/woooooooooooooosh
      retarded moron who doesn't know shit about science has spoken .

    • ElPayasoMalo
      ElPayasoMalo  1 weeks back

      @aaradhy sharma Homeopathic principles are definitely not what did it for sure. The only thing it can cure is dehydration.

    • aaradhy sharma
      aaradhy sharma  1 weeks back

      Bro homeopathy has cured my mother kidney stones. And the surgeon himself said my mother look for homeopathic alternative. She got first stone remove by laser surgery. Second was from homeopathy.
      (What actually happened that taking medicine increased water intake hence stone got passed)
      Or the medicine actually helped.

    • ElPayasoMalo
      ElPayasoMalo  1 months back

      If you decide to do these videos in Klingon, I'll help.

  • 356porwa
    356porwa  3 hours back

    So homeopathy is all bullshit??

    • CoolCreeper39
      CoolCreeper39  5 hours back

      3.3k Karens disliked this

      • sharazisspecial
        sharazisspecial  2 days back

        I thought Homeopathy was just herbal remedies. It’s actually worse then I thought! Who the hell is dumb enough to buy mostly water.

        • Rahat Khan
          Rahat Khan  2 days back

          Well, a homeopathy medicine cured my diarrhea

        • Liam Birch
          Liam Birch  2 days back

          Homeopathy is great man I cured my atherosclerosis with sandalwood essential oil boom gone and my hair loss too way cheaper than regular medicine that’s why people used to live so much longer back in the day

          • WebX
            WebX  2 days back

            "Like cures like" with "diluted versions of something that causes the disease" is probably how homeopathy stuck. When it doesn't help, it does nothing. But if it is doing so using certain viruses or bacteria taken from other sick people, you have essentially created a vaccine. An absolutely glorious irony regarding homeopathy believers.

            So if it doesn't work, it does nothing. But when it helped, it could potentially REALLY help.

            I would argue that homeopathy probably became vaccines in much the same way that superstitious alchemy became chemistry.

            • Amar Jyoti Kutum
              Amar Jyoti Kutum  3 days back

              Homoeopathy is miracle.. In chronic disease... We're there is no gross pathological damage to the organ.. Allopathy is great in emergency.. Life saving.. Prolonged intack of allopathy leads to severe side effect.. So for safety homoeopathy for emergency Allopathy.. Both are good in there own pillars.

              • Johnhitbox
                Johnhitbox  3 days back

                3.3k essential oil sales people hate scientific facts.

                • Jessica Hackett
                  Jessica Hackett  3 days back

                  For me.....when I do homeopathic medicine I don't freaking buy shit from snake oil salesman. I use the actual ingredients.
                  Ex. Vicks is great for helping ease congestion. Vicks is made with petroleum jelly, eucalyptus oil and camphor. So I buy eucalyptus oil and camphor oil, put them into a humidifier and breathe in the steam. Does the same damn thing as the Vicks without having to waste petroleum or paying a much higher price.

                  • wanda plain
                    wanda plain  4 days back

                    dear people who read more about placebos.... that not even a drugs... please know the difference between a real drugs and a placebos.... 😂

                    • wanda plain
                      wanda plain  4 days back

                      it doesn't matter which system of medicine work... u can call it sugar water or not... but the fact is that even if u take modern world medicine (allopathy) if your body won't react to it u will die.... yes homeopathy drugs are prove in human.... modern medicine prove there drugs in lower animals.... so are u saying proving on human is wrong and you accept that your body is exactly react like lower animal....
                      one more thing tell me why modern medicine... keep on changing there drugs after few years the medicine will be banned or not permitted to sale because they are considered dangerous to human.... and please name at least one real drugs that has been banned from homeopathic drugs.....leave placebo... there alot more of drugs other from belladonna that can treat u accordingly to your modalities...every human is unique... even Identical twin are unique in there own way.... FYI they treat human not animals... behavior of animals and humans are completely different.... if you want to talk shit about homeopathy please do your research deeply... not superficial

                      • Japan Gaming! 日本語

                        5:40 don’t hug me I’m scared clock

                        • Dr. Limbo
                          Dr. Limbo  5 days back

                          I.e. it's the less harmful version of "traditional Chinese medicine".
                          It's about as effective, but doesn't cause entire species to approach extinction.

                          • Evil Badger
                            Evil Badger  5 days back

                            I have no idea what homeopathy is and this video did not explain it well at all. I feel jipped whatching this video so I'm going to dislike.

                            • Kisaragi
                              Kisaragi  5 days back

                              Is it bad that I've literally never heard of homeopathy before this video, 18 years old btw.

                              I mean I know about the placebo affect and old remedies but not this specifically.

                              • Jessica Hackett
                                Jessica Hackett  3 days back

                                Research is key. If you buy shit from a mass producer it will be crap. But if you actually do real research you will find that there are remedies that do work because the ingredients actually work.
                                Simple example.
                                Vicks has 3 primary ingredients
                                Petroleum jelly
                                Eucalyptus oil
                                Camphor

                                If you buy a bottle of 100% eucalyptus oil and a bottle of champor oil then put 3 to 5 drops of each into hot water breathing in the steam will do the same thing Vicks does without wasting petroleum and those bottles will last a Heck of a lot longer.

                                Snake oil salesman are just that, fakes.

                            • Narendra Kumar
                              Narendra Kumar  5 days back

                              I m a Homoeopath nd this type of videos/comments are not new to us....
                              Homoeopathy has helped in innumerable cases of end stage diseases , if its just water ,, how it can be so ??
                              If smbody say, its placebo effect....., y cant just anybody start giving placebo nd cure the disesses....

                              • Narendra Kumar
                                Narendra Kumar  3 days back

                                @Hm Grraarrpffrzz
                                As u r nt able to tell about yr education , u r telling many things about you.......
                                Placebo effect --: Tell me how infants/plants/animals will hav placebo effect...., anyway i m a medicos to know more about placebo ...
                                R allopathic doctors fools to hv consultation fr thrmselves nd fr their patients ...
                                If u r so curious about its working , go to a homoeopath for few weeks , nd u will know if its work or not....merely listening to sm videos/papers/article has made u blind to search fr truth...

                              • Hm Grraarrpffrzz
                                Hm Grraarrpffrzz  3 days back

                                @Narendra Kumar _"How much educated u r ?? What work do you do ??
                                Plants / babies having placebo effect ??? My goodness...."_
                                As said:
                                1) You do not understand the placebo effect.
                                2) You do not want to understand the placebo effect, because having your homeopathic nonsense confirmed is more important to you than finding the truth. You rather spread and believe in lies than finding out that you were wrong.
                                3) Neither you, nor anybody else, has any scientific evidence that homeopathic is more than a placebo effect.
                                4) Neither you, nor anybody else, can explain in detail how homeopathy would work.

                                You are either a scam artist or don't care about what is true.

                                If you are so convinced that it works, why don't you prove that it works? Approach other scientists, conduct a large scale experiment and prove to the world that homeopathy works.
                                You'd be the first person in history capable of doing that. You'd become instantly rich and famous. You'd prove that homeopathy would be more than a billion dollar scam to sell sugar water to those in desperate and rob them offtheir money.

                              • Narendra Kumar
                                Narendra Kumar  3 days back

                                @Hm Grraarrpffrzz
                                How much educated u r ?? What work do you do ??
                                Plants / babies having placebo effect ??? My goodness....
                                And what about lots of allopathic doctors taking for themselves or their relatives or referring the patients...., Does it mean that Allopathic doctors r fool to take placebo , if so they could hav taken/ given for themselves or others or their patients....

                                I m convinced nd so i practice...., For earning there r lots of other ways.....

                              • Hm Grraarrpffrzz
                                Hm Grraarrpffrzz  4 days back

                                @Narendra Kumar _"Yes there must be research on how it works ...., just criticising as placebo effect just dnt make any sense..."_
                                It has been researched. The result is:
                                1) It doesn't work any better than the normal placebo effect.
                                2) Nobody can explain in detail how it could theoretically work.

                                If nobody can explain how it could work, and if nobody can prove that it works, and if experiments show that it does not work... why on Earth do you defend this nonsense? Because you earn your money that way?

                                _"How does it work on newborn
                                How does it act on plants/animals..."_
                                In other words: you don't know a lot about the placebo effect.

                                You are not interested in the truth. Same as highly religious people, you just choose what you would like to be true, and pretend that it is true, even if it's not.

                            • Ravenn
                              Ravenn  5 days back

                              From what I know, I agree homeopathy is bull, but people have to stop assuming any type of medicine or health practice made by Asians is bull. That’s just racist. Does anyone know how much scientific evidence is behind meditation, yoga or tai chi? Isn’t there some kind of reason why Japan has the longest lifespan of any country in statistics? What about Asian countries in general compared to the rest of the world? Oh come on. Asian food is also just healthier. Just look it up online if you want to know more.

                              • Abu Bakr Guy
                                Abu Bakr Guy  6 days back

                                In all fairness, you should now make a video on the fraudulant and corruptness of the allopathy as well. Treats the symptoms not the cause! Atleast be fair in your comparison. Your comparison made it look like that the early homeopath were giving water and sugar pills to people with war wounds! Ofcourse they would not.. So a good comparison would be a life-long allopathic medicine which I have to take for ages, with little to no real effect except numbing my body to the pain (steroids and opioids) .. How does that sound for "MEDICINE". I got fixed for my recurring headache, I just have to continue chugging down drugs like a junkie!

                                • Raiyne Hutton
                                  Raiyne Hutton  6 days back

                                  YO WHY DID YOU INCLUDE TONY THE TALKING CLOCK D:<

                                • Sourav Dey
                                  Sourav Dey  6 days back

                                  Does it work??? Yes...
                                  Can you trigger placebo effect on your own?? No...
                                  Then who cares it's a hoax or not???

                                  • Hm Grraarrpffrzz
                                    Hm Grraarrpffrzz  5 days back

                                    1) The promises made by homeopathy describing doctors are lies.
                                    2) By spreading the belief in homeopathy, you are spreading ignorance. You are teaching people that magical miracle tinctures are true. You are trying to drag mankind back into barbarism.
                                    3) The billions of money stolen from people that way could be spent on something useful, rather than dumbing people down.
                                    4) Homeopathic promises can lead to people not going to the doctor for getting actual help, and rather relying on magic and sugar water. This can lead to them going to the doctor when it's too late.

                                • Troy1941
                                  Troy1941  6 days back

                                  Homeopathy
                                  _Did you mean_ Placebo?

                                  • GUTO CASTELO GUTO
                                    GUTO CASTELO GUTO  6 days back

                                    Homeopaty is a lie!!!!!!!!!

                                    • harshbarj
                                      harshbarj  7 days back

                                      12 seconds in. "How does homeopathy work". Easy, it does not.

                                      • tarnenflastJUMP
                                        tarnenflastJUMP  7 days back

                                        THAT'S what homeopathy is??? I always thought it sounded fishy but I would never have guessed they are literally just selling people water.

                                        • Raghu Seetharaman
                                          Raghu Seetharaman  7 days back

                                          Other issues with modern medicine is (1) Hospitals and medical professionals selling souls to Big Pharma and (2) A lack of natural and preventative measures before administration of medicine, and (3) Lack of compassion and patient-centered care.

                                          The benefits, however, include the scientific rigor and evaluations of modern medicine. This video is absolutely on the money. Allopathic medicine is a *whore* to insurance companies and big pharma while Homeopathic medicine is an unscientific *con artist* fooling you into thinking they are actually treating you.

                                          • Narendra Kumar
                                            Narendra Kumar  5 days back

                                            Homoeopathy is genuine...., plz visit any good homoeopath...., u vill know it...
                                            Yes, theoratically it seems nonsense...

                                        • Raghu Seetharaman
                                          Raghu Seetharaman  7 days back

                                          I have four homeopathic doctors in my family. They all live in India. They are really fun-loving, but namely ignore the fact that their health practice really does nothing for their patients. Their patients are mostly poor and they can offer their services very cheap. With India's largely spiritual population, the "placebo" effect is greater with homeopathic treatment than normal. Poor people who can't afford allopathic care look on homeopathic doctors with revery and honor, almost like a priest.

                                          It's bizarre, but in predominantly religious and science-ignorant societies, I feel the placebo effects of homeopathy can actually rival modern medicine.

                                          • Youtube University
                                            Youtube University  7 days back

                                            Homeopathy is more a lesson in bedside manner and diet.

                                            • Daniel Checko
                                              Daniel Checko  7 days back

                                              Aaaaaaaaaa!?,..??!?,

                                              • Jim Bob
                                                Jim Bob  1 weeks back

                                                Perhaps even homeopathic doctors don't know why, but homeopathic remedies work often

                                                We live in a world where we still give incredibly dangerous and toxic allopathic remedies such as accutane to teenagers for mild acne - even when allopathic remedies work, they often come with horrendous side effects

                                                Perhaps time to expand your horizons slightly

                                                • Hm Grraarrpffrzz
                                                  Hm Grraarrpffrzz  7 days back

                                                  _"but homeopathic remedies work often"_
                                                  How do you know that it's them that works, and not a placebo effect or something else?

                                                  _"even when allopathic remedies work, they often come with horrendous side effects"_
                                                  And without them, lots of people would die or suffer horribly. But it's easy to call medicine evil if you don't depend on it, I guess.

                                              • Aaden Diaz
                                                Aaden Diaz  1 weeks back

                                                How 2 become rich:
                                                1. get a permit
                                                2. sell sugar water and label it as "Homeopathy"
                                                3. get money
                                                4. have people riot outside your house since your sugar water is losing its effects
                                                5. *GET SUED FOR TAX FRAUD*

                                                • hi hello
                                                  hi hello  1 weeks back

                                                  did you know that 100% of people who vaccinate die?



                                                  EDIT:this is a joke if you dont get it everybody dies one day

                                                • Soulon Howland
                                                  Soulon Howland  1 weeks back

                                                  Don't Hug Me I'm Scared clock?

                                                • Luc Fauvarque
                                                  Luc Fauvarque  1 weeks back

                                                  How would you estimate the actual effectiveness of the placebo effect? Knowing that it is primarily working on people ignorant of its inner workings, how much does homeopathy affects credulity in your opinion? Following this question, how much of an hazard does homeopathy creates that luring people into thinking they will get better... instead of getting real meds? Finally, how much weight does the wellness argument bears when homeopathy is in direct competition with actual services like psychology, massage, spa and the likes? Their effects are not very different, but their services are real, unlike those out of price sugar pills or sips of water. Ones are harmless services with actual work. The others are overpriced sugar and water sold as a lie.

                                                  • Voltaic Fire
                                                    Voltaic Fire  1 weeks back

                                                    I've got my own source of homoeopathic "medicine" at home. In the trade it's called a kitchen sink.

                                                    • Voltaic Fire
                                                      Voltaic Fire  1 weeks back

                                                      I really wish homoeopathy was outlawed, at best it does nothing and at worst it kills people. All the while taking money from the ignorant.

                                                      • Voltaic Fire
                                                        Voltaic Fire  1 weeks back

                                                        A nice, cute video explaining the idiocy of homoeopathic bullshit merchants.

                                                        • duckhwii duckhwii
                                                          duckhwii duckhwii  1 weeks back

                                                          WHY ARE WE NOT TALKING ABOUT THE CLOCK FROM DHMIS

                                                          • WD Preston
                                                            WD Preston  1 weeks back

                                                            No porn!!!!!?????

                                                            • Abu Saleh Hridoy
                                                              Abu Saleh Hridoy  1 weeks back

                                                              Soooo the less of the substance the person ingests, the better it works. Soooooo just don't take any of it, SUPER CURE!

                                                              • What The Fun
                                                                What The Fun  1 weeks back

                                                                It definitely works!... I have homeopathic medicines...I recommend to use it!

                                                                • Adam Mason
                                                                  Adam Mason  1 weeks back

                                                                  Sorry, but you are wrong.... an *Englishman* trying to explain the values of those who *fought the English and won* ??!?

                                                                  • VaultBoyGamer
                                                                    VaultBoyGamer  1 weeks back

                                                                    I think if you are sick and you treat yourself with homeopathy and regular medicine its good but just one type of those two types of cures is an imbalance

                                                                  • Jez
                                                                    Jez  1 weeks back

                                                                    One day a patient rushed into his homeopathic doctor's clinic. "Doctor, please help me! I've taken a huge overdose by mistake! What should I do?"

                                                                    The doctor asked him how he'd managed to take an overdose.

                                                                    "I forgot to take my pill this morning!"

                                                                    • karen dougdeen gokool
                                                                      karen dougdeen gokool  1 weeks back

                                                                      Gentle and harmless 😇🤗 or harmful and rough 😡👿

                                                                      • Tyler
                                                                        Tyler  1 weeks back

                                                                        People can't be that gullible, right?

                                                                        Haha, right?

                                                                        ...right? :-(

                                                                        • Voltaic Fire
                                                                          Voltaic Fire  1 weeks back

                                                                          Ask EA, when they're not counting their lootbox money that is.

                                                                      • kubbaa2
                                                                        kubbaa2  1 weeks back

                                                                        "Homeopaths take one part of solution and mix it with nine parts of water diluting it down to one tenth of its original concentration, and shaking it..." oh god it sounds like an alchemy. Are we live in 21th century?

                                                                        • Bubbascuba
                                                                          Bubbascuba  1 weeks back

                                                                          As the great James Randi says, "homeopathy is a bunch of woo."